Must-Have Insurance for Used Car Dealers in Oklahoma: What Every Lot Needs to Stay Protected

Steven Conway • June 9, 2025

Oklahoma’s weather isn’t the only thing threatening your lot—protect your dealership with the right insurance strategy

Running a used car lot in Oklahoma isn’t easy. You’re dealing with test drives that don’t always come back clean, surprise hailstorms, walk-in customers, and paperwork that has to be perfect.

You’re not just selling cars—you’re managing risk every single day. And without the right insurance, one unexpected event can cost you everything you’ve worked for.

This guide breaks down the coverages that matter most for used car dealerships across Oklahoma—from Tulsa to Altus and everywhere in between.

Why Used Car Lots Face More Risk Than You’d Think
  • Test Drives – One bad turn and your truck’s in a ditch.
  • Customer Accidents – Oil spots or uneven pavement can lead to injury claims.
  • Oklahoma Weather – Tornadoes, hail, and strong winds are regular guests.
  • Theft or Vandalism – Open lots can be targets after hours.
  • Paperwork Problems – One wrong title or missed disclosure can lead to legal action.

โœ… Garage Liability Insurance

What it covers: This protects you if your business causes bodily injury or property damage—especially during test drives.

Even if a customer crashes during a test drive, you’re on the hook. This coverage helps pay for the other driver’s repairs or medical bills.

Example: A customer test-drives your pickup and rear-ends another car. Garage liability helps cover the third party’s damages so you’re not writing a check yourself.

Note: This won’t pay for damage to your own vehicle being test-driven. That’s what Dealers Open Lot coverage is for.

โœ… Garagekeepers Insurance

What it covers: Vehicles on your lot that you don’t own—like trade-ins, consignment cars, or customer vehicles in for service.

If something happens while those vehicles are in your care, this coverage helps pay to repair or replace them.

Coverage Options (and Why They Matter):

๐Ÿงพ Legal Liability

You’re only covered if the damage is your fault. If someone breaks in overnight and trashes a car? No coverage. If your employee forgets to lock the doors and it’s stolen? That’s on you—and this policy pays.

Best for: Dealers who rarely store customer cars and want a basic option.

๐Ÿ“„ Direct Excess

This pays after the customer’s own insurance is used. It’s a backup. You’re still covered—but not until their policy is applied first.

Best for: Lots with moderate customer vehicle exposure that want more than bare minimum coverage.

๐Ÿ›ก Direct Primary

This is the best coverage. It pays first, no matter who’s at fault or what the customer’s insurance says.

  • No arguing.
  • No waiting on the customer to file a claim.
  • Just fast resolution.

Example: A hailstorm dents four trade-ins left on your lot. With Direct Primary, you handle the claim and repairs quickly—no finger-pointing or delays.

Best for: Dealers with overnight storage, high traffic, or exposure to Oklahoma weather.

โœ… Dealers Open Lot (DOL) Coverage

What it covers: The cars you own—the ones you’re actively selling. It protects your inventory from hail, fire, theft, vandalism, and collisions.

Tip: This policy is based on your total inventory value. Update it regularly to avoid being underinsured.

Example: A storm hits Moore and damages 30 vehicles on your lot. DOL coverage pays to repair or replace them—so you can restock and stay open.

โœ… Commercial Auto Insurance

What it covers: Vehicles you use for business—like shuttle vans, auction haulers, or parts runners.

Example: Your delivery van is rear-ended on the way to Norman. This policy covers the damage and helps with medical bills or legal claims.

Personal auto policies won’t cover business use. If the vehicle is titled to your business or used on the job, you need commercial auto.

โœ… Errors & Omissions (E&O) Insurance

What it covers: Paperwork mistakes, missing disclosures, or misunderstandings that lead to legal trouble.

Example: A buyer says you didn’t tell them about a branded title. Whether it was a true error or a miscommunication, E&O pays for your defense and any settlements.

This protects your business reputation—and your wallet.

โœ… Smart Add-Ons You Should Consider

  • False Pretense Coverage – Protects you when someone poses as a buyer and steals a vehicle.
  • Title Bond Insurance – Covers claims tied to missing or incorrect vehicle titles.
  • Business Interruption Insurance – Replaces lost income if your operations shut down due to fire, storm, or vandalism.
  • Hired and Non-Owned Auto – Covers vehicles your business doesn’t own—like employee cars used on the job or short-term rentals.
Why Local Knowledge Makes a Big Difference

Oklahoma is a rate-and-file state. That means insurers can change prices fast—especially after a bad hail season or when crime rates shift.

Working with a local insurance expert gives you:

  • Real insight into pricing in places like Tulsa, Altus, Enid, Lawton, and Broken Bow
  • Experience handling storm and theft claims
  • Advice tailored to Oklahoma’s dealer regulations—not generic national info
Why Oklahoma Dealers Trust Conway Insurance

We’ve worked with used car dealers across Oklahoma and Texas for over 20 years. From family-owned lots to franchise groups, we know the business, the risks, and the coverages that actually matter.

No fluff. No upselling. Just insurance that fits.

๐Ÿ“ž Let’s Keep Your Dealership on the Road

Running a car lot in Oklahoma takes grit, hustle, and a lot of moving parts. Let’s make sure insurance isn’t something you have to worry about.

Because in Oklahoma, it’s not if something happens. It’s when.

Recent posts

By Steven Conway June 11, 2025
If you own a business in Oklahoma—whether it's a coffee shop in Norman, a contractor in Moore, or a bakery in Edmond—you’ve probably asked yourself, “How much should I be paying for insurance?” It’s a smart question. Business insurance isn’t just a legal box to check. It’s about protecting your dream, your income, and the people who help make it happen every day. While our focus is on serving Oklahoma businesses, it’s worth noting that Conway Insurance is also licensed in Texas. So if you have operations across state lines or are expanding, we’ve got you covered there too. In this guide, we’ll break down what business insurance really costs, why it varies so much, and how you can keep premiums manageable without leaving yourself exposed. No industry speak. Just straight answers, examples from right here in our state, and a few tips from folks who’ve seen a thing or two. ๐Ÿง The Real-World Cost of Business Insurance in Oklahoma. Let’s start with the numbers. These aren’t just for OKC and Tulsa—we’re talking about the real-world costs faced by business owners from Altus to Miami, from Woodward to Idabel, and everywhere in between. On average, here's what small business owners in Oklahoma are paying each month: - General Liability : $50–$125 - Commercial Property : $75–$250 - Workers’ Compensation (per employee): $90–$300 - Commercial Auto : $100–$175 per vehicle - Business Owner’s Policy (BOP) : $100–$275 ๐Ÿ’ก Pro Tip: Bundling policies into a BOP can save you up to 25%—and keep the paperwork to a minimum. Last month, we worked with a contractor in Moore who was paying over $6,000 annually through a direct carrier. After reviewing their setup, we bundled their coverage through two A-rated carriers and dropped their premium to $4,700—plus added inland marine coverage they didn’t even know they needed. Their response? “Why didn’t someone show me this sooner?” ๐Ÿง Why Insurance Costs Vary from Business to Business? We get this a lot: “Why is my friend’s insurance cheaper than mine?” And the answer is, it depends. Insurance is priced based on risk—and risk looks different depending on what you do, where you are, and how much coverage you need. Your industry is a major factor. A retail store has fewer hazards than a construction company. Your location matters too. Businesses in hail-prone or high-crime ZIP codes will generally pay more. Then there’s your payroll and revenue. Higher revenue typically means more exposure, and more employees means a bigger workers’ comp bill. Your claims history also plays a role. If you’ve had several recent claims, your rate will reflect that. But if you’ve been claim-free, you may qualify for credits or preferred pricing. ๐Ÿ’ฐ How to Pay Less Without Cutting Coverage? Let’s be honest: Nobody loves paying for insurance. But there are ways to get the coverage you need at a price that doesn’t sting. a. Bundle everything you can. That’s why BOPs exist—to combine liability and property into one, simplified (and discounted) plan. b. Ask about discounts. You’d be surprised how many carriers offer savings for things like monitored alarms, e-signatures, or safety training. c. Control your losses. Prevent claims by maintaining safe workplaces, training staff, and checking equipment regularly. Carriers reward businesses that take risk seriously. d. Review your policy every year. Businesses evolve. So should your coverage. We’ve seen folks still paying premiums based on outdated revenue or property values. e. Work with an independent agent . Captive agents are tied to one brand. We’re not. At Conway Insurance , we look at the whole market to find the best fit you — not just the “in-house” option. ๐Ÿ’ฌ A client in Yukon put it best: “I thought I was covered until y’all pointed out two gaps in my old policy. Now I’ve got better protection and I’m paying less. It was a no-brainer.” ๐ŸŒช๏ธ Business Insurance Isn’t Just a “Nice to Have”. We live in Tornado Alley. That means storms, hail, wind, and unpredictable weather are just part of life. But there are other risks too— data breaches , customer injuries, and even broken HVAC systems during a heatwave. One uninsured event can wipe out everything you’ve worked for. Good business insurance gives you staying power. Whether you're a bakery in Edmond, a tech startup in OKC, or a landscaping crew in Mustang, the right policy keeps your business running when the unexpected happens. We’re not here to scare you—we’re here to help you sleep better at night. ๐Ÿ—“๏ธ Ready to Talk Through Your Options? We’re Conway Insurance , and we’ve helped thousands of Oklahoma business owners—and many in Texas too—get protected without overpaying. We’ll ask the right questions, explain the fine print, and recommend coverage that makes sense—not just for today, but for where you’re headed. ๐Ÿ“ž Call us at 405-733-2886 ๐Ÿ“… Or schedule your appointment online Let’s make insurance one less thing you have to stress about. Email us directly at steven@conwayinsuranceok.com if you'd rather reach out by message than schedule a call. โœ… Wrapping It Up. Every business is different. But one thing’s true across the board: the right insurance can make or break your future. Don’t guess. Don’t settle. Let’s find the coverage that fits—without the fluff, the hard sell, or the hidden fees. We’re Conway Insurance —based right here in Oklahoma and proudly licensed to serve Texas too. We’ve got your back.
By Steven Conway June 3, 2025
How to Avoid a Financial Disaster