Umbrella Insurance: Is it Worth It?

Steven Conway • September 9, 2024

Umbrella Insurance: Is it Worth It? 

                                   
There is a perception that umbrella insurance is an unnecessary or optional expense. Umbrella insurance may, nevertheless, be a prudent investment, given the potential risks and financial exposure faced in today's litigious environment. 
 
How does umbrella insurance work? 
 
You can purchase umbrella insurance to provide additional liability coverage in addition to your homeowners, auto, and other primary policies. This coverage is designed to provide an additional safety net if these underlying policies cannot provide sufficient dollar amount of liability coverage. 
 
The cost of umbrella insurance 
 
In general, umbrella insurance is not as expensive as you might think. A policy that covers $1 million may cost between $150 and $300 per year. There are a variety of factors that can affect this amount, including your location, the amount of your coverage, and any additional risks you may face. An umbrella policy is inexpensive compared with the financial damage that a substantial claim could cause. It can be beneficial to increase your financial security. 


How are umbrellas be used in real-life situations?



Imagine you accidentally run a red light while driving, resulting in a multi-car pileup. There have been numerous injuries and extensive property damage reported. Liability limits can easily be exceeded by medical treatment, vehicle repairs, and potential lawsuits.

An unlevel patio can cause a guest to trip and require surgery and months of rehabilitation. Besides medical expenses and lost wages, the guest sues for pain and suffering beyond the homeowner's insurance policy limit.


Your negative comment about a business on social media leads to a lawsuit for defamation. A standard homeowner's insurance policy does not cover libel, slander, or defamation claims unless you add and pay for this coverage. Even if you have added this coverage to your homeowner's policy, it may be insufficient. In either case, umbrella policies may cover legal expenses and judgments or settlements.


A neighbor's child is seriously injured by the dog you own. The parents sue for emotional distress, medical bills, and financial damages on behalf of the child and wins. The awarded amount exceeds your homeowner's limits.


In the event your teenager causes a car accident that results in significant injuries to the occupants of another vehicle, the medical and legal expenses could exceed the liability limits of your car insurance policy.


You are sued for medical expenses, pain and suffering, lost wages and attorney fees after a visitor trips and falls on your rental property. These could exceed your landlord's liability insurance coverage.


While operating your boat, you collide with another vessel, causing injuries to passengers and damage to the other boat. There could be substantial claims for injuries and property damage all exceeding your boat insurance policy.

In summary, obtaining an umbrella policy could protect your personal assets from being used to pay for damages that exceed the limits of your insurance policy at an affordable rate while 


Please note that the information provided in this article is intended for general informational purposes only and may not apply to your specific situation. Insurance laws and regulations can vary significantly from state to state, and it’s crucial to understand the specific requirements and coverages that apply to your location. We strongly recommend consulting with a licensed insurance agent in your state to discuss your unique needs and ensure you have the appropriate coverage for your circumstances.

Recent posts

Oklahoma restaurant owner reviewing an insurance checklist with storm clouds over Oklahoma City
By Steven Conway November 10, 2025
Oklahoma restaurant insurance for 2025, covering tornadoes, floods, liquor liability, cyber, EPLI, and business interruption. Local help from Conway Insurance.
By Steven Conway November 7, 2025
I spend my time in Oklahoma restaurants, not just on the phone. I talk with owners, managers, chefs, and bar leads. I’ve seen the back office, the dish pit, the walk-in, the patio heaters, and the POS that freezes at 6 pm. I know what really derails a week. My job is to match insurance to the way you run service, so one bad hour does not wreck your month. Here’s what matters and how it fits together. The Core Coverage You Cannot Skip General Liability Start here. A guest slips on rainwater near the host stand in Midtown. A kid bumps a space heater on the patio in Norman. A to-go order triggers a peanut allergy. General liability covers bodily injury and property damage you are legally responsible for. Most policies also include personal and advertising injury (things like defamation, slander, or copyright). Some carriers exclude or limit this—so confirm it’s included and not excluded on your policy. Important note: When you sell or serve alcohol as a business , standard CGL typically excludes liquor liability. That exposure is handled by a separate Liquor Liability policy . (More on this in Part 2.) Commercial Property Think building (if you own it) and everything inside that makes you money: hood systems, fryers, ovens, walk-ins, lowboys, POS, tables, chairs, bar stock, dish machine, signage, heaters, even that neon sign your photographer loves. This is Oklahoma—hail, wind, freezes, and long hot spells hit equipment hard. Property coverage is your repair/replace budget for major damage when a covered cause of loss strikes. Two details make or break your claim: Replacement Cost vs. Actual Cash Value (ACV): Replacement cost pays what it takes to buy new equipment today. ACV deducts depreciation, leaving you short. Confirm which your policy uses. Coinsurance: Many policies include a coinsurance clause. If you insure below true replacement value, claim payments may be reduced proportionally. Confirm your requirement. Don’t forget exterior signs . Freestanding or roof-mounted signs take wind hard in Oklahoma and often need to be scheduled with a real dollar amount. Business Income and Extra Expense Power goes out in Edmond on a Friday. You lose the prime rib for Saturday plus the sales you needed to cover payroll. Business income replaces lost net income and pays unavoidable expenses like rent, payroll, loan payments, and utilities. Extra expense covers costs to reopen faster—temporary refrigeration, a generator, rush parts. Ask for: Utility Service Interruption (off-premises power outage) Civil Authority (your street is blocked after a nearby fire/tornado) Equipment Breakdown Property insurance loves fire/wind/water—but not internal failure. Equipment breakdown covers sudden, accidental mechanical or electrical breakdowns: HVAC boards, compressors, dish machine controls, POS systems. It’s inexpensive and saves more claims than owners expect. Food Spoilage and Contamination Two related but different protections: Spoilage: Pays when food is lost due to outage or equipment failure. Contamination: Pays when health authorities require you to discard product or sanitize. Some carriers add PR/crisis response. Don’t guess your spoilage limit. Walk the cooler, total meats/seafood/dairy/produce/sauces/prep—and add a cushion for holidays or event weekends. Workers’ Compensation If you have employees, Oklahoma law generally requires workers’ comp. It covers medical costs and a portion of lost wages (cuts, burns, slips, strains) and protects you from most employee injury lawsuits. Owners/LLC members/family can often be included or excluded by election—check your filing. Lowering cost long-term: track hood cleanings/grease trap service and slip incidents; enforce non-slip shoes; train new hires on lifting. Carriers reward documentation. Common Mistakes to Avoid Low spoilage limits (don’t insure $2,000 if your walk-in can hold $8,000) No utility service coverage (outages are more common than fires) ACV instead of replacement cost Coinsurance penalties from underinsuring Assuming liquor liability is included (it usually isn’t for alcohol businesses) “Set and forget” workers’ comp payroll estimates (audit pain later) Ready for Part Two This post covers the backbone. In the next post, we’ll dig into liquor liability, hired/non-owned auto, cyber, EPLI, leases, and Oklahoma “gotchas.” Coverage needs and limits vary by operations and contracts. This article is educational only and does not guarantee coverage. Review your policy with a licensed independent agent. For a no-pressure review, call 405.733.2886 , email steven@conwayinsuranceok.com , or visit ConwayInsuranceOK.com .