Fraud Affects Us All
Steven Conway • December 15, 2024
Fraud Affects Us All
The insurance industry is facing a significant challenge today in the form of insurance fraud. The cost of this crime to insurers and policyholders is billions of dollars every year. Even though some may believe it's a victimless crime, insurance fraud affects everyone's premiums.
Fraud in the insurance industry: What is it?
An insurance fraud occurs when someone deceives an insurance company to gain financially. Staging accidents, inflating claims, falsifying insurance applications, and falsifying insurance applications are just a few examples of insurance fraud. Despite their apparent isolation, these actions affect all policyholders. As a result of fraudulent claims or misrepresentations, insurers' costs rise, leading to higher premiums for honest consumers.
Premiums that are too high and insurance fraud are prevalent
Insurance fraud occurs when someone intentionally deceives an insurer for financial gain. Insurance companies suffer from fraudulent activities as well as consumers, whose premiums increase as a result. Here are the steps:
1. A higher payout for claims
Paid fraudulent claims add to the overall losses to the carrier. The carrier in turn will increase premiums for everyone to cover all losses both legitimate and fraudulent.
2. High operating costs
For insurance companies to detect and prevent fraud, advanced fraud detection technologies, specialized investigators, and training programs must be invested. The additional operational costs lead to higher premiums.
3. Detailed underwriting of the project
The data used by insurers to set premiums can be skewed by fraudulent claims. Insurance premiums may rise for everyone in that risk group if fraudulent activity alters insurance statistics.
4. Lack of trust
A high level of fraud may lead insurers to be more cautious about accepting higher-risk policyholders. The insurer may increase premiums for everyone, even those at low risk of filing fraudulent claims, to mitigate the increased risk.
5. Claims are becoming more difficult to process
Fraud slows down the claims process. Processing time and costs increase due to the need to thoroughly investigate fraudulent claims. As a result of this delay, insurance companies incur higher costs.
---
Fraudulent activities related to insurance
Fraud in the insurance industry takes many forms, and each type affects rates differently.
1. Staging accidents to defraud insurers
The purpose of staging accidents is to collect an insurance payout. This can be accomplished by fabricating fake witnesses, exaggerating injuries, or causing damage to property.
In areas where this fraud is prevalent, insurers often raise rates for all insured because of staged accidents.
2. Exaggerated claims
An example of this type of fraud is when policyholders inflate the severity of their losses, regardless of whether the loss was caused by an auto accident, property damage, or a personal injury. Insurance companies may overestimate damages or injuries incurred by insureds.
Exaggerated claims result in higher premiums for consumers.
3. False medical claims (fraudulent health insurance claims)
A false health insurance claim involves billing for treatments that were not provided or exaggerating the cost of those treatments. A claim could also be submitted for a procedure or treatment that does not exist.
Fraudulent medical claims cause healthcare costs to rise, forcing health insurers to raise premiums.
4. Falsifying application information
Underreporting income, failing to disclose a preexisting medical condition, or failing to disclose a hazardous occupation are examples of falsifying insurance applications. A misrepresentation can cause an insurer's risk assessment to be skewed. The carrier will fail to collect appropriate premium based on the risk characteristics.
When an insurer pays out a claim based on fraudulent information, everyone's premiums rise. As a result of these misrepresented risks, insurers have to increase their rates.
5. Theft of property insurance (arson)
Arson fraud occurs when a person intentionally burns down their own property to collect an insurance payout.
As a result of the costs associated with processing and paying arson claims, insurers charge higher premiums. Consequently, property owners, especially those in high-arson areas, can expect to pay higher premiums.
6. Fraudulent claims for workers' compensation
The purpose of workers' compensation fraud is to collect benefits that employees are not entitled to by fabricating or exaggerating their injuries. Employers can also misclassify workers to reduce their insurance premiums.
7. Fraudulent life insurance policies
Faking a death, submitting false death certificates, or staging a suicide to collect a death benefit are all examples of life insurance fraud. Insurers face this less often, but it is still a serious issue.
8. Inflated or false theft claims (auto insurance fraud and homeowner's insurance fraud)
False claims for stolen property are submitted in this type of fraud. It is possible for policyholders to claim their belongings were stolen when they weren't, or to exaggerate the value of their stolen items.
9. Fraud in the healthcare industry
Health care providers can also commit fraud by submitting false claims or overcharging for services that were not rendered. Overbilling and unnecessary procedures are examples of this.
The Scope of Insurance Fraud Statistics
The financial impact of insurance fraud is staggering. Fraud accounts for approximately 5-10% of all insurance claims, according to the National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB). Every year, billions of dollars are lost to fraudulent activities, resulting in higher premiums for all policyholders. The cost of insurance fraud in the United States alone is estimated to be around $80 billion annually, which is passed on to consumers.
Fraudulent insurance claims have far-reaching consequences
Fraud in the insurance industry is more than just a crime -- it raises costs for everyone. A variety of fraudulent activities raise insurance rates, including staged accidents, exaggerated claims, and health care provider fraud. Policyholders pay higher premiums as a result of insurers passing on these costs.
In addition to becoming aware of the risks and combating fraud through vigilance, consumers can also report suspicious activity to the insurance industry once they understand the types of fraud and how they affect the insurance industry. By reducing fraud, keeping premiums low, and ensuring fair pricing, all parties benefit.
Please note that the information provided in this article is intended for general informational purposes only and may not apply to your specific situation. Insurance laws and regulations can vary significantly from state to state, and it’s crucial to understand the specific requirements and coverages that apply to your location. We strongly recommend consulting with a licensed insurance agent in your state to discuss your unique needs and ensure you have the appropriate coverage for your circumstances.
Recent posts
Oklahoma restaurant insurance for 2025, covering tornadoes, floods, liquor liability, cyber, EPLI, and business interruption. Local help from Conway Insurance.
I spend my time in Oklahoma restaurants, not just on the phone. I talk with owners, managers, chefs, and bar leads. I’ve seen the back office, the dish pit, the walk-in, the patio heaters, and the POS that freezes at 6 pm. I know what really derails a week. My job is to match insurance to the way you run service, so one bad hour does not wreck your month. Here’s what matters and how it fits together. The Core Coverage You Cannot Skip General Liability Start here. A guest slips on rainwater near the host stand in Midtown. A kid bumps a space heater on the patio in Norman. A to-go order triggers a peanut allergy. General liability covers bodily injury and property damage you are legally responsible for. Most policies also include personal and advertising injury (things like defamation, slander, or copyright). Some carriers exclude or limit this—so confirm it’s included and not excluded on your policy. Important note: When you sell or serve alcohol as a business , standard CGL typically excludes liquor liability. That exposure is handled by a separate Liquor Liability policy . (More on this in Part 2.) Commercial Property Think building (if you own it) and everything inside that makes you money: hood systems, fryers, ovens, walk-ins, lowboys, POS, tables, chairs, bar stock, dish machine, signage, heaters, even that neon sign your photographer loves. This is Oklahoma—hail, wind, freezes, and long hot spells hit equipment hard. Property coverage is your repair/replace budget for major damage when a covered cause of loss strikes. Two details make or break your claim: Replacement Cost vs. Actual Cash Value (ACV): Replacement cost pays what it takes to buy new equipment today. ACV deducts depreciation, leaving you short. Confirm which your policy uses. Coinsurance: Many policies include a coinsurance clause. If you insure below true replacement value, claim payments may be reduced proportionally. Confirm your requirement. Don’t forget exterior signs . Freestanding or roof-mounted signs take wind hard in Oklahoma and often need to be scheduled with a real dollar amount. Business Income and Extra Expense Power goes out in Edmond on a Friday. You lose the prime rib for Saturday plus the sales you needed to cover payroll. Business income replaces lost net income and pays unavoidable expenses like rent, payroll, loan payments, and utilities. Extra expense covers costs to reopen faster—temporary refrigeration, a generator, rush parts. Ask for: Utility Service Interruption (off-premises power outage) Civil Authority (your street is blocked after a nearby fire/tornado) Equipment Breakdown Property insurance loves fire/wind/water—but not internal failure. Equipment breakdown covers sudden, accidental mechanical or electrical breakdowns: HVAC boards, compressors, dish machine controls, POS systems. It’s inexpensive and saves more claims than owners expect. Food Spoilage and Contamination Two related but different protections: Spoilage: Pays when food is lost due to outage or equipment failure. Contamination: Pays when health authorities require you to discard product or sanitize. Some carriers add PR/crisis response. Don’t guess your spoilage limit. Walk the cooler, total meats/seafood/dairy/produce/sauces/prep—and add a cushion for holidays or event weekends. Workers’ Compensation If you have employees, Oklahoma law generally requires workers’ comp. It covers medical costs and a portion of lost wages (cuts, burns, slips, strains) and protects you from most employee injury lawsuits. Owners/LLC members/family can often be included or excluded by election—check your filing. Lowering cost long-term: track hood cleanings/grease trap service and slip incidents; enforce non-slip shoes; train new hires on lifting. Carriers reward documentation. Common Mistakes to Avoid Low spoilage limits (don’t insure $2,000 if your walk-in can hold $8,000) No utility service coverage (outages are more common than fires) ACV instead of replacement cost Coinsurance penalties from underinsuring Assuming liquor liability is included (it usually isn’t for alcohol businesses) “Set and forget” workers’ comp payroll estimates (audit pain later) Ready for Part Two This post covers the backbone. In the next post, we’ll dig into liquor liability, hired/non-owned auto, cyber, EPLI, leases, and Oklahoma “gotchas.” Coverage needs and limits vary by operations and contracts. This article is educational only and does not guarantee coverage. Review your policy with a licensed independent agent. For a no-pressure review, call 405.733.2886 , email steven@conwayinsuranceok.com , or visit ConwayInsuranceOK.com .